III

_____________________________________

Comments on the Constitutional Norms

 

Comments to the Article 151

 

(17) Equal and unequal tax treatment: in search of balance

 

55. For taxes purpose, the equal treatment among the legal entities which constitute the Brazilian State in a same level of power is what permits the existence of the State structure: the Federal Union can not prefer, e.g. a specific Municipality, giving to it incredible preferences concerning to taxes, by reason of this can bring a disturb in the hierarchical federal structure.

56. The same, in a most basic perspective, applies to the territorial element in taxation: unequal federal taxation in different territories inside the same federal jurisdiction implies in a problematic sensation to citizens concerning their rights of citizenships.

57. By other side, in a country with continental dimension, there are a lot of unequals areas in an economical sense, being a duty of the State change this scenario, because the power of a State is directly related to the union of its constitutive elements, what is more difficult when there is a great difference of power among these elements.

58. Not treat the taxpayers in a so unequal way (with taxes which are not uniform in all Brazilian territory), nor in a so equal way (not considering the necessity of promote strategic regions) must be the main purpose of the Federal Union. Find the balance is the key perspective.

 

contents | previous | next

___________________________
All rights reserved. Prohibited to copy and distribute, without permission of Rafael De Conti

 

CONTACT for legal advice

 

Rafael De Conti, Rafael Augusto De Conti, Brazilian Tax Lawyer, Lawyer in Brazil